Selecting the right journal for your research manuscript is more than just a logistical step—it’s a strategic decision that can significantly affect your chances of acceptance and the visibility of your work. This article takes a more in-depth look at one of the top 5 research paper mistakes—choosing a journal whose aims and scope do not align with your study.

Why the Aims and Scope Matter

Every academic journal defines its aims and scope to clarify the type of content it seeks to publish. These statements outline the disciplines covered, preferred methodologies, populations of interest, and theoretical or clinical emphasis. Submitting to a journal without carefully reviewing this information often leads to quick desk rejections, regardless of your paper’s quality.

For example, if your study examines the effects of a cognitive-behavioral intervention on anxiety in adolescents, it may be a poor fit for a journal focusing primarily on neurobiological mechanisms of anxiety disorders in adults. A better choice might be Journal of Adolescent Health or Cognitive and Behavioral Practice, both of which explicitly welcome applied clinical research in youth populations.

The Overlooked Opportunity: Special Issues

Many journals periodically release calls for papers for special issues—collections of articles centered on a particular theme. Submitting to one of these offers a unique opportunity to frame your research in a way that directly contributes to a curated scholarly conversation.

Suppose you’ve conducted a qualitative study exploring psychiatric stigma among immigrant populations. Instead of submitting it to a general psychiatry journal, you might find a better home in a special issue on “Cultural Perspectives on Mental Health” from a journal like Transcultural Psychiatry or Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology. Not only does your topic fit squarely within the scope, but it also aligns with a currently prioritized theme, increasing your chances of acceptance and readership.

How to Strategically Choose Your Journal

Here are a few steps to guide your decision:

1. Study the aims and scope of your top candidate journals—not just for keywords, but for tone, preferred topics, and methodological preferences.
2. Review recent issues to see what kinds of studies the journal typically publishes.
3. Search for open calls for special issues via the journal’s website or platforms like Elsevier’s Special Issue Finder or Wiley’s Call for Papers portal.
4. Consider impact factor and audience—but don’t over-prioritize prestige. Relevance and readership are often more valuable than a high impact factor alone.

Let Helix Editing Help

At Helix Editing, we specialize in polishing research papers for journal submission. Our Premium Editing service includes thorough language and structural edits, inline comments, and a detailed Editor’s Report that specifically evaluates your manuscript’s fit with your target journal’s aims and scope. If you want to submit with confidence, contact us today.

‍